Session 29

Withdrawing from a class can be a quick way to get out of a bad grade. But a lot of students aren’t sure how that W on your transcript will affect your chances for medical school.

Does withdrawing from a class look bad for medical school? Withdrawing will only look bad for medical school if there is a suspicious pattern, such as repeatedly withdrawing and then taking the classes at community college instead. Otherwise, having a few withdrawals does not look bad.

[00:42] What’s Worse For Med School Apps, a C or a W?

It’s a common email I get from students: Should they drop a class they’re struggling with it? They’re wondering if their withdrawal will hurt their chances of getting into medical school more than a bad grade in that class.

What’s going to be worse? On the one hand, you could get a C, then retake the class and get an A (hopefully). Then you average out to a B.

On the other hand, you could take a W, then retake the class and get an A (hopefully). Then you have an A average rather than the B above. That’s one way of looking at it.

[01:15] Will a W Look Bad for Medical School?

The answer is no, but also yes. A single withdrawal is not going to hurt you. But if you have several withdrawals in your college experience (say, one during Freshmen year, one during Junior year, one during Senior year), this might look fishy. It’s the pattern of withdrawing from classes that you should try to avoid.

Other details could make it look worse, too. For example, you withdrew from your organic chemistry course at your four-year university. And then during the next semester, you took it at a community college next door. That might look a little fishy.

And if you did that several times, for all the courses you decide to withdraw from, that might look especially fishy.

[Related episode: Can I Get Grades Removed From My Transcript to Help My GPA?]

[02:40] Single and Multiple Withdrawals

Having a W on your application is not a huge deal unless there’s a larger pattern of concern for the admissions committee members.

If somebody sees a pattern, that may raise some red flags. So if there are some health or family issues that caused you to withdraw from classes in a suspicious pattern, then talk about it briefly in your personal statement.

If you have withdrawals from a whole semester of classes, like you withdrew from every class one semester, that may warrant addressing briefly in a personal statement, too. But there are many understandable reasons to withdraw.

[04:00] It’s an Issue of Consistency

Ultimately, the biggest question is this: Are your transcripts showing admissions committee members that you can handle the coursework of medical school? Consistent withdrawals can suggest you may not be able to handle the coursework of medical school.

But a single withdrawal isn’t going to raise a red flag, and neither will a couple of withdrawals. So if you’re struggling with one of your classes right now, give yourself permission. Withdraw from that course. Figure out why you weren’t doing well. And go back and tackle it next time and get an A.

Links:

Related episode: Should I take a C or Withdraw From My Class?

Related episode: Can I Get Grades Removed From My Transcript to Improve My GPA?

Related episode: From a 2.7 Undergrad GPA to First Year Medical Student

Need MCAT Prep? Save on tutoring, classes, and full-length practice tests by using promo code “MSHQ” for 10% off Next Step full-length practice tests or “MSHQTOC” for $50 off MCAT tutoring or the Next Step MCAT Course at Blueprint MCAT (formerly Next Step Test Prep)!